Ethics Dilemma Paper Essay

ETHICS DILEMMA PAPER unrivalled of the most difficult things in the criminal dependableice field is link to ethics in the criminal justice profession. Whether it beingness a division of corrections officer, police officer, or a judge. The main goal is to ensure you as a headmaster are qualification the right conclusion for the great good and that it falls within the guidelines that are set before you in the laws that fetch been written. In the recent dilemma that occurred in Broward County on February 19, 2014 is an fount of an ethics dilemma in the criminal justice field that happens oft too often. I will explain to you the nature of the dilemma, the ethical/ wrong decision that was made, the outcome of the situation, and suggest some alternative marks of actions that could wealthy person interpreted place instead and why.NATURE OF THE DILEMMAOn February 19, 2014 a Broward County Sheriffs replacement of 20 plus years on the attract conducted a traffic stop of a vehicl e traveling unlawfully in the HOV (High Occupancy Vehicle) lane. Once the substitute had the vehicle stopped he was assured by the cleaning woman in the drivers seat that she was arranging him conducting the traffic stop. Once the sheriffs deputy gained knowledge of this he proceeded to force play his way into the womans vehicle trying to grab her phone, accordingly pulling her out of the vehicle and dragging her onto the ground causing injuries in several places as a nonher deputy stood by with his gun posen. all(prenominal) the while this was going on he continued to yell at her stating she was committing a felony and telling her I know the law better than you , and placing her under arrest. The ethical dilemma this situation brings forward is was the actions taken by this deputy really necessary and justified on an ethical basis? (Miller, 2014). good DECISION MADEIn this particular situation an unethical decision was made based on the spate of the incident at softwo od. The deputy was committing a crime (felony) himself by unlawfully forcing his way into her vehicle, and detaining her against her will for a crime she did not commit. All for a childly civil usurpation (driving in an HOV lane), that could lose been handled in a totally different and professional manner. This was the only law the woman was breaking at the clock, and the only apparent cause the deputy had to go on for the actions that he took.OUTCOME OF THE smearOnce the dust settled upon this unfortunate situation, the deputy assumed and position that the woman was breaking the law by recording the auditory sensation and pictorial matter of the deputy. He assumed that he had to give the woman permission to audio record him. Unfortunately to his disadvantage the Florida courts ruled upholding a expectation of silence provision (Silverman, 2012) to their all-party law, which the courts ruled does not apply to on-duty police (or anyone in public), as long as you are not int erfering with them in conducting their duty. In this particular case the deputy appeared to be uneducated in this decree to the law that the law enforcement agency clearly neglected to educate its department on.ALTERNATIVE COURSES OF ACTION/ WHYAccording to the situation at hand some of the alternative courses of actions that the deputy could suck taken and the woman that was being stopped could have been drastically different. Ethically speaking the deputy could have not taken his actions to the extreme that he did all over the simple recording violation that he thought the woman was committing. His life was not in danger nor was there any indication of any sensual threat coming from the woman. The deputy totally handled that situation in a very unprofessional and unethical manner.On the other hand the woman could have easily been justified in using deadly force on the deputy if he was not a law enforcement officer. She would have been justified well within the guidelines of Fl oridas Justifiable Use of oblige law considering he unlawfully forced his into her car and violently dragged her out. fortuitously for him he was a law enforcement officer or he could have been killed.Another course of action for the sheriffs deputy and the department could have been to properly educate themselves and their officers of the most current laws regarding these types of situations. In addition to making sure each and every deputy gets a refresher course on the necessary use of force procedures every few years. findingIn conclusion of this ethical dilemma situation, what I can draw from this is several things. One being always treat people in a way I would like to be treated unless circumstances dictate otherwise it is the right and ethical action to take. Sometimes we just do not get that luxury of doing such an action when relations with certain types of people and situations and yes certain actions are necessary. Always take the time to educate yourself on certain l aws or information you are not sure of before acting on what you think may be correct. Just like the famous saying, Ignorance of the law is not an excuse, and this is very true but it does go both ways for law enforcement and the public.ReferencesMiller, C. (2014). photography is not a crime. Retrieved from http//photographyisnotacrime.com/2014/02/19/broward-sheriffs-deputy-violently-attacks-woman-recording-traffic-stop/Silverman, S. (2012). Reason.com free minds and free markets. Retrieved from http//reason.com/archives/2012/04/05/7-rules-for-recording-police